Plan Sponsors Favor CITs for Private Market Access

As the Department of Labor moves toward finalizing its new rules governing private market investments in defined contribution plans, a growing number of plan sponsors are turning to collective investment trusts as the preferred structure for adding private equity and real estate exposure to participant portfolios. The regulatory shift is expected to clarify how these alternative assets can be offered while preserving fiduciary safeguards.
Recent product launches illustrate the momentum. Manulife John Hancock Retirement introduced a CIT-based private-equity option, Constitution Capital Partners rolled out a real-estate focused trust, Principal added a diversified private-market vehicle, and Goldman Sachs debuted a multi-strategy offering aimed at retirement plans.
Beyond the CIT Structure
Advisers who evaluate these vehicles are urged to look past the legal wrapper and focus on the underlying investment strategy, the liquidity mechanisms embedded in the trust, and the track record of the managers who run the assets, according to remarks made during a Natixis Investment Managers panel held in New York. The discussion emphasized that the form of the product matters less than the substance of what investors are actually buying.
Sara Cassidy, managing director at AEW Capital Management, highlighted that while private-market opportunities can enhance diversification, the right access point is important for plan participants. She noted that many plans lack the internal expertise to evaluate these complex assets directly, making a well-structured CIT an attractive gateway.
“From an operational perspective, as well as on some fiduciary responsibilities for DC plans or DC advisers, one of the ways that these investments become attractive is through a CIT,” Cassidy explained during the session.
CITs Dominate Target-Date Funds
Data released by industry analysts show that CITs now account for the majority of private-market exposure inside target-date funds. They hold 55% of target-date assets as of June 30, a rise from 42% at the beginning of the decade. This growth reflects the increasing comfort of plan sponsors with the CIT model.
The trend stands in contrast to the way defined benefit plans traditionally allocate to private markets, where pension trustees often rely on separate account structures or direct commitments to private-equity firms. The CIT format offers a pooled-vehicle alternative that aligns more closely with the contribution-based nature of DC plans.
Cassidy pointed out that DC plans have distinct liquidity and rebalancing requirements compared with pension funds. Because participants can shift contributions at any time, plan sponsors must ensure that any private-market exposure can be adjusted without causing material disruptions.
“DC plan participants are expecting liquidity when they need it, based on their 401(k) plans,” she added, stressing that the timing of cash flows is a critical design consideration.
Liquidity Mechanisms in CITs
One common approach to managing liquidity is the inclusion of a liquidity sleeve that holds cash or publicly traded securities. This sleeve can be used to meet redemption requests and to perform regular portfolio rebalancing without forcing the sale of illiquid private assets.
When advisers compare different CITs, they should examine the composition of the underlying assets, the historical performance record, and the drivers that are expected to generate future returns. These factors together shape the risk-adjusted profile of the trust.
“We think about the performance of our vehicles and performance of strategies as being critical to being able to support the capital flows coming into the space,” Cassidy said, highlighting that strong past results are often a proxy for the manager’s ability to work through the private-market cycle.
Liquidity Remains a Key Consideration
Eric Deram, founder and CEO of Flexstone Partners, observed that the secondary market for private-fund interests has matured, providing a more reliable source of liquidity for investors who need to exit positions before the underlying assets are fully realized.
“The secondary market in private equity has become really efficient,” Deram noted, adding that price discovery and transaction speed have improved markedly over the past few years.
He also mentioned that, despite the growing interest, private-market allocations in DC plans are expected to represent only a small portion of total plan assets. Most of the liquidity needed by participants will continue to be satisfied through public market investments such as stocks and bonds.
Cassidy agreed that secondary transactions enhance overall market liquidity, but she expects defined contribution plans to benefit indirectly. Rather than participating directly in secondary deals, plans will likely rely on the CIT structure to pass on the liquidity advantages to their participants.
Adoption Will Take Time
The proposed DOL safe harbor is viewed as a positive step toward broader use of private-market CITs, yet Cassidy believes that regulatory clarity alone will not trigger immediate, large-scale adoption. She argues that plan sponsors need more than just rule language to feel comfortable shifting significant assets into these vehicles.
“I think it will take more than just the rule to push for it,” she said, indicating that education and operational readiness are equally important drivers of change.
Education is essential, as advisers, plan sponsors, and participants must understand how private-market investments fit within the broader DC plan framework and what trade-offs they entail. Clear guidance on valuation methods, liquidity expectations, and fiduciary duties will help reduce uncertainty.
“I don’t think the adoption, the takeoff, is going to happen immediately,” Cassidy concluded. “I think it’s going to be a very slow ramp up.”