Vanguard releases plan to boost U.S. retirement savings

Vanguard has released a policy wish list for the potential SECURE 3.0 Act, aiming to improve retirement outcomes for American workers. The paper, titled “Six Big Ideas for Improving U.S. Retirement Outcomes”, proposes several measures to increase retirement savings and participation.
Boosting Participation and Savings
One key proposal is to allow employees to make payroll deductions into an individual retirement account (IRA). This could close the participation gap by 60% for the 65 million workers without access to employer-sponsored plans. Vanguard estimates this would provide 22.7 million workers with an average of $90,000 in retirement savings by age 65.
The paper also suggests expanding automatic enrollment to all employers sponsoring retirement plans, excluding small businesses. This could generate nearly 17 million new participants with up to $186,000 in additional savings by age 65.
Removing Frictions in the System
Vanguard’s Fiona Greig highlights a “second bucket” of proposals focused on removing frictions. This includes allowing default investment options for IRAs, addressing the issue of 28% of separating employees leaving funds as cash for seven years or longer.
The firm also proposes increasing the default saving rate to 6%, as currently, 27.7 million workers are automatically enrolled below this threshold. Additionally, Vanguard calls for immediate eligibility for contributions and immediate vesting to minimize periods of ineligibility and reduce forfeitures, which disproportionately affect lower-income participants.
To improve account portability, Vanguard suggests standardizing digital infrastructure for rollovers, which could yield $14,000 in additional savings for the 17.5 million workers switching jobs annually.
As discussions around SECURE 3.0 continue, Vanguard’s proposals aim to build on the progress made by previous legislation, addressing the fact that only two in five people are on track for retirement readiness.
Related Post: EU proposes social media ban for minors
It would allow employees to allocate certain employer contributions among various benefits, including retirement savings and student loan repayment.
With 6.5 million rollovers and 12.5 million accounts converted to cash annually, the potential impact of these proposals on retirement savings is significant. The average additional savings by age 65 could range from $7,000 to $186,000, depending on the measure and assumptions.
The American Retirement Association and other trade groups have expressed support for the OPTIONS Act, which aims to provide workers with greater flexibility in managing their benefits.
Addressing Legal and Administrative Hurdles
Official bids for SECURE 3.0 legislation began earlier this month. Representatives Bobby Scott and Mark DeSaulnier introduced three bills during this session. These bills address three specific areas for retirement plan participants. They concern the standing to sue, the definition of a fiduciary, and mandatory arbitration clauses.
The OPTIONS Act is another key piece of proposed legislation. Senators Todd Young and Cory Booker introduced this bill on November 10. It amends the Internal Revenue Code to allow employees to choose how they receive certain employer contributions. Workers can select from a list of options for these funds.
The list of options for employer contributions includes retirement savings accounts. It also includes student loan repayment, health savings accounts, and health reimbursement arrangements. The bill would codify an IRS private letter ruling from 2024.
Representatives Greg Steube and Suzan DelBene introduced a companion bill in the Senate in April. The American Retirement Association, the Chief Human Resources Officer Association, and the ERISA Industry Committee issued statements in support of this bill. These groups back the effort to provide workers with more choices.